A house divided: CS Muturi bold stand against government inaction on abductions and killings

In a riveting interview on Citizen TV, Public Service Cabinet Secretary Justin Muturi openly criticized his own government over the escalating cases of abductions and extrajudicial killings in the country.
His candid remarks have not only exposed deep-seated issues within the broad-based administration but have also sparked a political firestorm, with allies of President William Ruto calling for his resignation.
Muturi’s fervent stance is deeply personal. In June 2024, his son, Leslie Muturi, was abducted by state agents—a harrowing experience that has fueled his determination to address these injustices.
Recounting the ordeal, Muturi revealed that it was only through President Ruto’s direct intervention that his son was released.
“When the director-general of the National Intelligence Service confirmed they had my son Leslie, the president’s order was ‘you release him,” Muturi recounted.
During the interview, Muturi slammed the government for failing in safeguarding its citizens. He emphasized the urgency of addressing the rising incidents of abductions and extrajudicial killings.
“I am calling upon Mr. President to order an immediate end to these abductions and killings. You promised Kenyans that this would never happen.”
Muturi further advocated for transparency and justice, urging for an open inquiry into these incidents.
“We must establish an open inquiry to examine how these things have been happening. We cannot normalize this,” he asserted.
Boycotting cabinet meetings: A stand for justice
In a move that underscores his commitment to the cause, Muturi has abstained from attending cabinet meetings until the issue of abductions and killings is addressed. He explained his decision, stating, “I have sought to be excused from the cabinet meetings until the issue of extrajudicial killings and abductions is addressed by the cabinet.”
Muturi’s outspoken criticism has not been well-received within the Kenya Kwanza Coalition. National Assembly Majority Whip Sylvanus Osoro issued a stern warning, threatening impeachment if Muturi does not apologize to President Ruto. Osoro accused Muturi of inciting the public against the government.
“You have three options: First, resign. Second, apologize. And the third one is we impeach you. You cannot serve the government of Kenya that you criticize every day.”
But despite mounting pressure, Muturi remains resolute in his position. He dismissed calls for his resignation, emphasizing his dedication to constitutional values and the rule of law.
“Speaking on such matters should not be grounds for resignation,” Muturi asserted. Adding that, Resigning is a sign of cowardice.”
“The constitution is clear. A State official can resign in case of gross violation of the constitution,bankruptcy and unsound mind.I have not violate any local and International laws.”
Muturi’s revelations have shed light on a disturbing trend of abductions and extrajudicial killings in the country. Human rights organizations have raised alarms over the increasing number of enforced disappearances, often implicating state security agencies. The lack of accountability and transparency has eroded public trust in law enforcement and the government’s commitment to human rights.
The public’s response to Muturi’s interview has been polarized. While some commend his bravery in speaking out against injustices, others view his actions as a betrayal to the administration he serves. Social media platforms are abuzz with debates, reflecting a nation grappling with issues of governance, accountability, and human rights.
The President’ silence: An ominous Sign?
Notably, President Ruto has remained silent on the matter, neither addressing Muturi’s allegations nor the broader issue of abductions and killings. This silence has fueled speculation about internal rifts within the administration and the president’s stance on human rights abuses. Muturi’s call for an open inquiry puts additional pressure on the president to take a definitive stand.
The allegations of state-sanctioned abductions and killings have not only domestic but also international ramifications. Kenya’s reputation as a stable democracy is at risk, potentially affecting foreign relations and investment. Muturi highlighted this concern, questioning how safe investors would feel.
“If they are reading stories of Kenya’s security forces abducting people and handing them to other countries.”
CS Justin Muturi’s bold stance has brought to the forefront critical issues of human rights, government accountability, and the rule of law in Kenya. As the nation watches closely, the administration’s response to these allegations will significantly impact Kenya’s political landscape and its commitment to democratic principles.
In the face of adversity and political pressure, Muturi’s unwavering demand for justice serves as a poignant reminder of the essential role of public servants in upholding the rights and freedoms of the citizens they serve.